Thank you for all of your help. The service was outstanding - all of my questions were answered promptly, everything ran smoothly

M. Elliot
  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas

Criminal Law - Pleading guilty? Make yourself the favourite!

Date: May 14, 2008

Authors: LAC Lawyers

In a large number of criminal cases a person will plead guilty. It is then up to his legal representative to submit what is called a plea in mitigation. In other words the advocate will make submissions to the Court for the purpose of obtaining the most lenient sentence possible. 

This is not an easy result to accomplish. A good advocate may address his submissions to the Judge or Magistrate, they need to have the ability to persuade the court them or at least to take them into account when handing down sentence.

Justice not only needs to be done but needs to be seen to be done. Thus a good advocate when making submissions is in the first instance trying to convince the court that their client is deserving of the Court’s discretion to extend leniency to their client. By doing this he enables the Judge or Magistrate to grant leniency if they are inclined to do so.
 
Many persons who plead guilty for offences ranging from drink driving to assault, robbery and fraud have problems which influence them to break the law. Behind assaults and drink driving offences there often exists a drinking problem. Behind robbery and fraud there often exist gambling or drug problems.

Factors the Court takes into account when sentencing include rehabilitation and the likelihood of reoffending. Defendants can make themselves favourites by recognising they have a problem and taking steps to address that problem at the earliest possible time. This means getting help or treatment for the problem and the sooner the better.

Do not be concerned that it will look to the Court like you are only doing this only to obtain leniency. So many people will not admit they have such problems until confronted with the stark reality that their problem has led them into Court. The Court needs to save time and resources. A plea of not guilty is not appreciated when it is clear the accused was the offender. The Court is concerned with the administration of justice. Leniency is a function of remorse and contrition and an acknowledgement that their is a problem that may be treatable will stand you in good stead.

By taking it upon yourself to get help you appear to be a person who has a genuine desire to overcome your problem. Of course treatment needs to be secured from expert clinicians whom the court will readily accept as experts in their field. For example with psychological maladies associated with criminal behaviour, psychiatrists are preferred to psychologists. irrespective once your advocate is armed with an experts report your chance of success is significantly improved as it allows for a wider range of possibilities which should be reflected in submissions made to the court.

  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas